A marine valuation is an opinion of value supported by evidence: the vessel's actual condition, her specification and equipment, her hours, and what comparable vessels are actually selling for in New Zealand. Wedding & Paine Marine provide valuations for insurers, lenders, lawyers, estates and owners.
Most valuation disputes come from confusing three figures that are not the same thing.
Market value is what the vessel would realistically achieve in the current New Zealand market, in her present condition, between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither under pressure. It is built from the condition assessment and from comparable sales evidence.
Replacement value is what it would cost to acquire an equivalent vessel, or to build new to the same specification, depending on the basis required. This is usually higher than market value and is used for some insurance and asset purposes.
Insured or agreed value is the figure the insurer and owner agree for the sum insured. It should reflect market value closely; if it is too low the owner risks averaging on a partial loss, and if it is too high the insurer may challenge a total loss.
Insurance: new policies, renewals, sum insured changes, and agreed value policies. Lending: banks and finance companies require an independent valuation before advancing against a vessel. Estates and probate: executors need a dated, defensible value. Relationship property and legal disputes: independent evidence of value at a point in time. Sale and purchase: to test an asking price or support a negotiation. Import, export and customs: value for duty. Company accounts: asset values for balance sheets and depreciation.
A valuation is not a desk exercise. We inspect the vessel to establish condition, because condition drives value more than any other single factor. We record the specification and equipment inventory in detail, because a well-equipped vessel is worth materially more than a stripped one of the same model. We record engine and machinery hours, service history and the age and condition of major items such as rigging, sails, electronics and safety equipment.
We then apply comparable sales evidence from the New Zealand market, adjusted for differences in age, condition, specification, location and equipment. Where the vessel is unusual or there are few comparables, we say so and explain the basis of the valuation rather than pretending to a precision the market does not support.
The report states the purpose and basis of the valuation, the date of inspection and the date of valuation, the vessel's identification and specification, a summary of condition, the equipment inventory, the comparable sales relied on, and the resulting figures for market and replacement value. It is signed by a Class 1 Commercial Marine Engineer and is suitable for insurers, lenders, solicitors and the Court.
Where condition deficiencies affect value, they are identified and reflected in the figure, with the reasoning stated.
Where a full condition survey has been carried out, the valuation is built on that evidence and is straightforward. Where only a valuation is required, we still inspect the vessel, but the scope is limited to what affects value rather than a full condition assessment. If we find something during the valuation that warrants a fuller look, we will tell you before you commit to a larger piece of work.
A valuation inspection is priced as a survey attendance, typically $900 to $1,200 plus GST depending on vessel size and complexity, and it is discounted where it is combined with a full condition survey. Travel is quoted separately outside the Auckland region.
Tell us the purpose, the vessel and the timeframe, and we will confirm scope and cost the same day.
Straight answers from our Class 1 engineers:
Every survey is carried out by a Class 1 Commercial Marine Engineer:
Wedding & Paine Marine survey vessels across all of New Zealand:
Also surveying in
Auckland · Whangarei · Tauranga · Christchurch · Nelson · Queenstown